Hotter in their prime: Belinda Carlisle or Susanna Hoffs?

[Winnow]

This is an important Friday work poll! Choose wisely!

Susanna Hoffs:



Belinda Carlisle: (post chunk)



You can mention other 80's artists but the poll is between these two and not about their music or voices (so don't say it's poorly worded!)

[Boogahz]

Where is the option for neither?

[Morgrym]

Hoffs had the bedroom eyes down, but Carlisle had the baby face innocence and was known to do the go go back stage on her groupies. I voted for Belinda for pure innocent slut factor.

[Aslanna]

Where is the option for neither?

I think that's called "Not voting". Give that a try and let us know how it works out for you!

[Boogahz]

Where is the option for neither?

I think that's called "Not voting". Give that a try and let us know how it works out for you!

I would, but since Winnow always complains about poll options, I expected him to get it right in his own...

[Arborealus]

Belinda before all that plastic surgery > Belinda after.

Susanna = not in the ball game

[Sylvus]

Susanna all the way.

[Winnow]

I went with Susanna Hoffs based purely off the part in Walk Like an Egyptian where she does the eye thing.

Carlisle had a good voice and I admired her "cheery" attitude. She always seemed to be having fun in her videos (although I think she had a huge coke habit and the song Vacation was written about her breaking the habit. I might be totally wrong about that)

Belinda couldn't dance, even by 80's "chicken dance" standards. (watch any Go-Go's video) and while Susanna probably couldn't either, she was wise enough to just stand there and look sexy and do "eye thing". Moral: know your limitations and play to your strengths!

[noel]

I voted Belinda. I had a huge thing for her back in '86... when I was 12.

[masteen]

I'd make a sex crime on either of them.

[Seebs]

Hoffs is marriage material - Belinda would do things to my cock that would please me -

I'm torn.

[Winnow]

Hoffs is marriage material

Nice marriage material!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5arzC4hmI_M

That one picks up about half way through.

[Waran]

Hoffs' eyes are amazing...

Hoffs for teh win

[Seebs]

Hoffs is marriage material

Nice marriage material!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5arzC4hmI_M

That one picks up about half way through.

I stand by comments and thoughts - even more so after watching this.

This is only between Hoffs and Carlisle - and near as I can tell - Ms. Hoffs would not have sucked off a Japanese tour bus for smack money - I think Belinda did that three times.

I mean - don't you still have dreams about Sue-Sue's tongue from Walk Like an Egyptian?

mmmmmmmmmmm

[Xatrei]

Belinda Carlisle gets my vote here, but next to Jane Wiedlin, Carlisle doesn't even register.

There used to be rumors that Carlisle had some very raunchy drug-fueled sex parties on tape from her early Go-Go's days. It would be interesting to see those if they exist.

[Leonaerd]

Hoffs looks like she'd do all sorts of damage in bed. She gets my vote.

[Winnow]

I stand by comments and thoughts - even more so after watching this.

This is only between Hoffs and Carlisle - and near as I can tell - Ms. Hoffs would not have sucked off a Japanese tour bus for smack money - I think Belinda did that three times.

I mean - don't you still have dreams about Sue-Sue's tongue from Walk Like an Egyptian?

mmmmmmmmmmm

Sexier, not sluttier! Belinda wins in a head to head slut contest with Susanna Hoffs.

Here's Hoffs with the most "modern" looking hairdo on David Letterman. She looks great in this video:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m3bqrYTb-Ew

Belinda looks hot, no doubt. I think Susanna has a more "real" look to her though.

A couple nice Belinda Carisle pics to balance things out:







Found here if pics Red-X

http://www.leninimports.com/belinda_carlisle.html

I found this thread on another forum listing best looking 80's singers.

Brings back some memories if nothing else!:

http://www.discovervancouver.com/forum/ ... C_ID=92113

[Mak]

Can't believe nobody mentioned Nancy Wilson from Heart until page 2. Sheesh!

[Taly]

it is so Susanna Hoffs

[Zaelath]

Yeah, Hoffs. And that's even with my preference for redheads (not that Belinda's a redhead, but looks it in a few pics that have been posted, where as Susanna couldn't pull that off)

[Chidoro]

Hoffs

It's not even close for me. Hell, I liked the brunette in the go-go's way more than belinda. my eyes were never even on her in th videos.

[Xatrei]

...Hell, I liked the brunette in the go-go's way more than belinda. my eyes were never even on her in th videos.

I'm not alone on this!!

Belinda Carlisle gets my vote here, but next to Jane Wiedlin, Carlisle doesn't even register.

Jane in Art Frahm tribute:

The Go-Go's & The Bangles all together (with chunky Belinda):

[Winnow]

Yeah, Jane looks like Elf Girl from the first season of H E R O E S and seemed to have the most talent out of the Go-Go's group. She did a few solo things here and there.

The lady on the left of that group shot looks like Steven Tyler from Aerosmith.