Selling used games/DVDs to become illegal?

General discussion about other games, links to reviews, demos, etc - let us know about whats up and coming

Moderators: Funkmasterr, noel

Post Reply
User avatar
Aslanna
Super Poster!
Super Poster!
Posts: 12373
Joined: July 3, 2002, 12:57 pm

Selling used games/DVDs to become illegal?

Post by Aslanna »

http://www.gamasutra.com/view/news/3037 ... _Games.php
Court Of Appeals Ruling Threatens Sale Of Used Games?

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit has upheld the right of software companies to deny consumers the right to resell their products.

The ruling came as the result of a long-standing case involving used computer software sales on eBay, but its wide-ranging implications could threaten the resale of all digital content, including video games.

The case involved the sale of copies of AutoCAD, software that defendant Timothy Vernor had picked up in an architect's office sale. Vernor then put the software up for sale on auction site eBay, complete with serial numbers and a reassurance that no versions were currently installed on any other machine.

However, AutoCAD's developer, Autodesk, claimed the End User License Agreement (EULA) that users agreed to before using the software stated that the program was merely licensed, not sold, and that the user's license was non-transferable.

Furthermore, the agreement specified that, if the user upgraded to a new version of the software, the old version had to be destroyed.

Autodesk claimed that the copies Vernor had obtained should have been destroyed. Vernor counter-argued that, as he had not agreed to any license, he was free to sell the copies on and, on the verge of being banned from eBay, sued Autodesk to protect his business.

The court affirmed Vernor's right to sell the used software in 2008, but Autodesk appealed and last week the Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit reversed the earlier decision.

The ruling aims to distinguish between when a piece of software is sold and when it is merely licensed, with the user potentially unable to resell if it's the latter. The judge presiding over the case said: "We hold today that a software user is a licensee rather than an owner of a copy where the copyright owner (1) specifies that the user is granted a license; (2) significantly restricts the user’s ability to transfer the software; and (3) imposes notable use restrictions."

The ruling could have severe implications for other forms of digital media that are subject to license agreements, potentially preventing users from selling on their used video games. Indeed, Electronic Arts' standard EULA, while not mentioning resale policy, explicitly states: 'This Software is licensed to you, not sold.'

Libraries that loan digital media could also be subject to restrictions following the decision. The American Library Association, fearing that publishers could now forbid rental or lending unless libraries agree to more expensive licenses, filed an amicus brief in the case, which the judges reportedly showed some sympathy for, before concluding that they were forced to follow precedent.

The Court did, however, state that: "congress is free... to modify the first sale doctrine and the essential step defense if it deems these or other policy considerations to require a different approach."
Have You Hugged An Iksar Today?

--
User avatar
Bubba Grizz
Super Poster!
Super Poster!
Posts: 6121
Joined: July 3, 2002, 12:52 pm
Gender: Male
Location: Green Bay, Wisconsin

Re: Selling used games/DVDs to become illegal?

Post by Bubba Grizz »

I wonder how something like this will effect companies that have licensed software and a turn over rate. Now that I am typing this out I guess it won't make much difference as most companies own a number of licenses and when there is turn over a new person is using the software but it is on a company machine. They aren't reselling the software.

However, what about upgrades? They mention that the old version needs to be destroyed?
User avatar
miir
Super Poster!
Super Poster!
Posts: 11501
Joined: July 3, 2002, 3:06 pm
XBL Gamertag: miir1
Location: Toronto
Contact:

Re: Selling used games/DVDs to become illegal?

Post by miir »

This is the reason stores that deal in used games no longer buy/sell used PC games.


Since consoles require the original disk be present to run games, their EULA is not as restrictive.
I've got 99 problems and I'm not dealing with any of them - Lay-Z
User avatar
Siji
Way too much time!
Way too much time!
Posts: 4040
Joined: November 11, 2002, 5:58 pm
Gender: Male
XBL Gamertag: mAcK 624
PSN ID: mAcK_624
Wii Friend Code: 7304853446448491
Location: Tampa Bay, FL
Contact:

Re: Selling used games/DVDs to become illegal?

Post by Siji »

Watching companies shoot themselves in the foot in a feeble attempt to make money is rather humorous. It hasn't worked for the music industry and it's not going to work for the software industry.
User avatar
Boogahz
Super Poster!
Super Poster!
Posts: 9438
Joined: July 6, 2002, 2:00 pm
Gender: Male
XBL Gamertag: corin12
PSN ID: boog144
Location: Austin, TX
Contact:

Re: Selling used games/DVDs to become illegal?

Post by Boogahz »

Now we just need to be able to force the companies to buy back their shitty software.
Post Reply